Few moments in the Star Wars saga have been as eagerly awaited or emotionally charged as the return of Luke Skywalker in the sequel trilogy. Introduced initially as a shining beacon of hope and heroism, Luke’s reappearance as a weary and disillusioned Jedi Master in Star Wars: The Last Jedi startled fans and critics alike. Far from the heroic figure many remembered, this version of Luke was burdened by failure and regret. However, a recent addition to Star Wars canon has provided a profound reinterpretation of Luke’s seemingly greatest failure — one that not only justifies his journey but deepens the legend of this iconic character.
Luke Skywalker’s Fall in Star Wars: The Last Jedi
When audiences first met Luke Skywalker, he was the embodiment of heroism and hope for the galaxy. But in The Last Jedi, released in 2017, viewers saw a different side: a broken man consumed by doubt and defeat. Luke’s journey took a dark turn when it was revealed that after a crisis of faith, he momentarily contemplated killing his nephew, Ben Solo, who later became Kylo Ren. This moment shattered Luke’s confidence as a teacher and Jedi, leading him to exile himself from the galaxy and the Jedi Order he once helped build.
Fans were divided by this portrayal — some found it a realistic evolution of his character, while others felt it undermined Luke’s heroic legacy. His failure to prevent Ben Solo’s fall to the Dark Side and the resulting devastation left Luke isolated and regretful. Even his teachings to Rey, the new hope for the Jedi, were tinged with his past failures, ultimately pushing Rey to reject him and seek Leia’s guidance instead.
Yoda’s Lesson: Failure as the Greatest Teacher
One of the most memorable moments in The Last Jedi was Luke’s encounter with Master Yoda’s Force Ghost. Here, Yoda reminded Luke — and the audience — of an enduring truth: “Failure, most of all, is the greatest teacher.” Reflecting on Luke’s struggles, Yoda’s message underscored that even the mightiest Jedi leaders are not infallible and that much of what we learn comes from our setbacks.
This scene reframed Luke’s errors not as shameful stains on his legacy but as vital lessons in humility and growth. However, some fans felt this moment was not sufficient to restore Luke’s honor or address the deep damage the sequel trilogy inflicted on his character. This left many yearning for a clearer redemption or a more definitive explanation.
Redeeming Luke: The New Canon Scene Between Luke and Kylo Ren
Star Wars finally delivered such clarity with Star Wars: Legacy of Vader #10, a new comic story set between The Last Jedi and The Rise of Skywalker. In this canon addition, Kylo Ren seeks out Luke Skywalker’s spirit, encountering him in the Force’s version of Heaven. This meeting reveals a much wiser, more serene Luke who understands the true nature of his failures.
Luke proudly acknowledges his lineage of legendary teachers — Yoda, Qui-Gon Jinn, and Obi-Wan Kenobi — all of whom were great Jedi but also faced significant failures. This lineage emphasizes that failure is intrinsic to mastering the Force and teaching others. Luke’s failures were not signs of weakness but essential steps in his growth as a Jedi Master and mentor.
This meeting helps fans see Luke’s journey in a new light: his setbacks and mistakes prepared the way for his true legacy — raising a new generation of Jedi who could succeed where he stumbled, including Rey and even potentially Kylo Ren. In essence, Luke’s story illustrates the vital cycle of teacher and student, where even the greatest masters endure failures to forge new hope.
Legacy of Luke Skywalker: A Lesson in Failure and Redemption
Luke Skywalker’s fall and redemption arc reflects a broader theme central to Star Wars mythology — that even the greatest Jedi are not immune to failure. His struggles humanize him, making his journey not just one of triumph but also of learning, humility, and perseverance.
This evolution of Luke’s character from a flawed teacher to a wise mentor who embraces his failures adds depth to the Star Wars saga. It also honors the complexity of the Jedi legacy, teaching us that failure is not the end but a powerful catalyst for growth.
Fans may continue to debate the portrayal of Luke in the sequels, but this new context from the comics restores balance by showing his ultimate acceptance of failure as a teacher. It reminds us why Luke Skywalker remains one of the most enduring and inspiring characters in Star Wars history.
Conclusion
The story of Luke Skywalker’s greatest failure and its eventual justification through one profound line embodies the heart of Star Wars — a saga deeply rooted in hope, resilience, and growth through adversity. From being a broken Jedi in The Last Jedi to a wise master embracing failure in the new canon, Luke’s journey teaches that even legends must stumble to rise again stronger.
Call to Action: Share your thoughts in the comments and explore more at keeperfacts.com.
